Sports Media
TheStar.com | Football | Time to throw red flag over NFL replays
Time to throw red flag over NFL replays
Email Story
Report Typo
AddThis

 

CHANNEL SURFING

THE GOOD: After quoting new Leafs GM Brian Burke on Toronto being the Vatican of hockey on the Hockey Night In Canada pre-game show Saturday, host Ron MacLean added, "He's right. The Stanley Cup and our Lord come around about as often." ... TSN's Special Olympics programming is worth a look, if for no other reason than the smiles on the athletes' faces.

THE BAD: After Saturday's boxing event on HBO, a victor described his opponent using a crude term that implied Oedipal qualities. Maybe it's time for a delay on athlete interviews.

THE UGLY: Don Cherry was at it again Saturday on HNIC, praising the Chicago Blackhawks for having, "19 North Americans, hockey players, one European." The CBC already has a seven-second delay on Cherry after his anti-Quebecois comments. It's time they used the same for this kind of talk.

Dec 01, 2008 04:30 AM

If you're one of those who will be there when the NFL makes what must be the most significant invasion of Canada since the War of 1812 on Sunday, you'd best bring some knitting or a Game Boy.

If the Miami-Buffalo game here is typical of the NFL product these days, you're going to have a lot of time to kill. And you can blame the league's replay challenge for that.

The merits of the replay challenge are debatable. Even with all those camera angles, the officials still get it wrong while taking time off our lives we'll never get back.

Regardless, the world of pro sports is convinced that it's necessary. After all, there are point spreads, I mean, victories hanging in the balance.

But if replay challenge is a necessary evil, then surely an organization as successful as the NFL can find a better way to do it.

Let's examine an 11-minute period during yesterday's New York Giants-Washington Redskins game, a stretch of tedium that no doubt had many viewers praying for a quick death.

A Giants pass was ruled incomplete as the two-minute warning sounded in the second quarter and seconds before Fox sent viewers to over two minutes of commercials.

When things resumed, viewers learned that New York had challenged the call. After a glut of replays and shots of semi-animated coaches standing on the sidelines, the play was overruled – almost four minutes after the original call.

But wait, it gets worse.

About two minutes later, the Giants came up short on fourth-and-one. Or so the officials said.

You guessed it, another review. After more replays and more shots of the coaches, we learned that the officials got it right the first time.

That's 3 minutes and 13 seconds more wasted for no good reason.

If you thought this was all some sort of high drama that kept viewers on the edge of their seats, here's the statistical breakdown of that 11 minutes:

Replays: 7

Shots of coaches: 8

Actual football plays: 7

Included in that sorry total was 6:21 spent on reviewing two plays.

Is it any wonder that so many NFL games are running past the three-hour mark? Heck, that's 1.5 NBA games or the first five innings of a World Series game.

The NHL has found a way to make replay review quick, painless and in most cases correct. During Saturday night's NCAA football game between Oklahoma and Oklahoma State, a play was reviewed in 76 seconds.

It takes NFL officials that long just to stick their heads into the replay camera.

The NFL is in the entertainment business. There's nothing entertaining about this.

czelkovich@thestar.ca

Advertisement
Advertisement
SPECIAL
You followed him last year while he quit smoking. Now David Bruser is back with a new goal: get in shape. Read his fitness blog and ...
Michael Sacco is interrupted by the root-canal screech of an electric saw. Upstairs, a crew is readying the next phase of his business ...
The heavens are making it abundantly clear that life on Earth is entering a dramatic period of change. Pluto, the ruler of ...
If there is a no-brainer forecast for 2009, it is that the world's favourite mutant, Wolverine, is going to be everywhere.
It took a visit to the doctor, some bad news and a camera crew to make the Thompsons tackle their health as a family.